4. Splitting large queries

Mark Padgham

Martin Machyna

2024-11-12

1. Introduction

The osmdata package retrieves data from the overpass server which is primarily designed to deliver small subsets of the full Open Street Map (OSM) data set, determined both by specific bounding coordinates and specific OSM key-value pairs. The server has internal routines to limit delivery rates on queries for excessively large data sets, and may ultimately fail for large queries. This vignette describes one approach for breaking overly large queries into a set of smaller queries, and for re-combining the resulting data sets into a single osmdata object reflecting the desired, large query.

2. Query splitting

Complex or data-heavy queries may exhaust the time or memory limits of the overpass server. One way to get around this problem is to split the bounding box (bbox) of a query into several smaller fragments, and then to re-combine the data and remove duplicate objects. This section demonstrates how that may be done, starting with a large bounding box.

library (osmdata)

bb <- getbb ("Southeastern Connecticut COG", featuretype = "boundary")
bb

#>         min       max
#> x -72.46677 -71.79315
#> y  41.27591  41.75617

The following lines then divide that bounding box into two smaller areas:

dx <- (bb ["x", "max"] - bb ["x", "min"]) / 2

bbs <- list (bb, bb)

bbs [[1]] ["x", "max"] <- bb ["x", "max"] - dx
bbs [[2]] ["x", "min"] <- bb ["x", "min"] + dx

bbs

#> [[1]]
#>         min       max
#> x -72.46677 -72.12996
#> y  41.27591  41.75617
#>
#> [[2]]
#>         min       max
#> x -72.12996 -71.79315
#> y  41.27591  41.75617

These two bounding boxes can then be used to submit two separate overpass queries:

res <- list ()

res [[1]] <- opq (bbox = bbs [[1]]) |>
    add_osm_feature (key = "admin_level", value = "8") |>
    osmdata_sf ()
res [[2]] <- opq (bbox = bbs [[2]]) |>
    add_osm_feature (key = "admin_level", value = "8") |>
    osmdata_sf ()

The retrieved osmdata objects can then be merged using thec(...) function, which automatically removes duplicate objects.

res <- c (res [[1]], res [[2]])

3. Automatic bbox splitting

The previous code demonstrated how to divide a bounding box into two, smaller regions. It will generally not be possible to know in advance how small a bounding box should be for a query for work, and so we need a more general version of that functionality to divide a bounding box into a arbitrary number of sub-regions.

We can automate this process by monitoring the exit status of opq() |> osmdata_sf() and in case of a failed query we can keep recursively splitting the current bounding box into increasingly smaller fragments until the overpass server returns a result. The following function demonstrates splitting a bounding box into a list of four equal-sized bounding boxes in a 2-by-2 grid, each box having a specified degree of overlap (eps=0.05, or 5%) with the neighbouring box.

split_bbox <- function (bbox, grid = 2, eps = 0.05) {
    xmin <- bbox ["x", "min"]
    ymin <- bbox ["y", "min"]
    dx <- (bbox ["x", "max"] - bbox ["x", "min"]) / grid
    dy <- (bbox ["y", "max"] - bbox ["y", "min"]) / grid

    bboxl <- list ()

    for (i in 1:grid) {
        for (j in 1:grid) {
            b <- matrix (c (
                xmin + ((i - 1 - eps) * dx),
                ymin + ((j - 1 - eps) * dy),
                xmin + ((i + eps) * dx),
                ymin + ((j + eps) * dy)
            ),
            nrow = 2,
            dimnames = dimnames (bbox)
            )

            bboxl <- append (bboxl, list (b))
        }
    }
    bboxl
}

We pre-split our area and create a queue of bounding boxes that we will use for submitting queries.

bb <- getbb ("Connecticut", featuretype = NULL)
queue <- split_bbox (bb)
result <- list ()

Now we can create a loop that will monitor the exit status of our query and in case of success remove the bounding box from the queue. If our query fails for some reason, we split the failed bounding box into four smaller fragments and add them to our queue, repeating until all results have been successfully delivered.

while (length (queue) > 0) {

    print (queue [[1]])

    opres <- NULL
    opres <- try ({
        opq (bbox = queue [[1]], timeout = 25) |>
            add_osm_feature (key = "natural", value = "tree") |>
            osmdata_sf ()
    })

    if (class (opres) [1] != "try-error") {
        result <- append (result, list (opres))
        queue <- queue [-1]
    } else {
        bboxnew <- split_bbox (queue [[1]])
        queue <- append (bboxnew, queue [-1])
    }
}

All retrieved osmdata objects stored in the result list can then be combined using the c(...) operator. Note that for large datasets this process can be quite time consuming.

final <- do.call (c, result)